I Baked My Boyfriend Crack Pie and This Is How it Turned Out

I Baked My Boyfriend Crack Pie and This Is How it Turned Out


Last month was my boyfriend’s birthday and he requested Christina Tosi’s Crack Pie (from Momofuku Milk Bar) for his birthday dessert.  I think it was a really busy weekend or I got in late the night before or something, so I was unable to make it. I know, I know, I’m horrible!  I tried to make up for it and baked the pie for Valentine’s Day.
I’ve had Crack Pie from Milk Bar a few times when I was in NYC, but it’s hard for me to remember exactly how it tasted and what it looked like.  I think because whenever I was there I ordered ten different things to try.  Sigh.

Besides the Compost Cookie, this is the only thing I’ve ever baked from the Milk Bar cookbook… this needs to change.  So this recipe was actually easier to make than I thought!  The first step is making a traditional oatmeal cookie batter  The batter is pressed onto a baking sheet and baked until crisp.


Meanwhile, you make the filling by whisking up heavy cream, melted butter, egg yolks, brown sugar, granulated sugar, vanilla and dried milk powder.  Sooo easy.  My hand looks giant in this picture.  It’s really not that big, I swear…. that’s just a tiny whisk.


The oatmeal cookie is crumbled up and mixed with softened butter and more sugar, then pressed into a pie dish.  Make sure you press it out as thinly as possible.  My crust was a little thick, so it was harder to slice.


The filling gets poured into the crust and baked for about 50 minutes or until golden brown and almost set.  Once again, sooo easy.

I really should get a camera, huh?  These pictures are not the most photogenic.  I’ve been shopping around a bit, but I don’t know what to get.  I don’t want to spend a ton of money because I’m not going to become a professional photographer.

I rapidly chilled the pie in the freezer after baking because this pie is supposed to be served cold, then dusted it with a coat of powdered sugar.  It was delicious and oh-so-crazy-rich.  Which obviously wasn’t a problem for me!  I probably could’ve eaten half of the pie.  It reminded me a lot of gooey butter cake except with an oatmeal cookie crust.

Here’s the recipe from Bon Appetit I used.



9 thoughts on “I Baked My Boyfriend Crack Pie and This Is How it Turned Out

  1. We recently bought this book and made their compost cookie and it was delicious! We even blogged about our experience. The crack pie is next on our list but Im honestly scared of how rich and buttery it will be – mostly concerned for our arteries haha

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Sue, it honestly was sooo good. I kind of loved it at room temperature as well.

    CookingwithteamJ, I’ll have to check out your post! Yes, you should be concerned, haha. There’s a TON of butter in there! Oh well…

    Grace, I find her really inspirational! She has worked so hard to be where she is now.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I have to say it’s too sweet for me — as I get older this happens more and more often, unfortunately. The flavor is good and I like the crust, but I’d like to try to make it just a little less sweet. Maybe some bittersweet chocolate in there? It’s probably my least favorite of the things I’ve made from the book so far.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s